This is a before and after image of Thomas Moore, an Indigenous boy who attended Regina Industrial School in Canada. These images were taken a few years apart. The image on the left was when Thomas arrived at the school, and the image on the right was taken around when he finished his time at the school. Notice the differences in his outfit, hair, and background.
The Regina Indian Industrial School was open from 1891 until 1910 and was one of many “Indian boarding schools” that operated between 1869 and the 1960s. In a boarding school, students live at the school, not with their families. Because Maine is so close to the border, Wabanaki children were sent to schools in both America and Canada.
While some Indigenous children attended the school voluntarily, many others were forced. They were taken from their families and brought to these schools where they were often not allowed to speak their native language, wear traditional Indigenous clothing, or act in other ways that reflected their culture. When students broke these rules, it was common for them to be severely punished.
These images of Thomas Moore were taken by government officials at the Department of Indian Affairs and were widely distributed as propaganda to show the benefits of Indigenous children attending these boarding schools.
Source 2 - Image
Source 2 - Image
Carlisle Indian School Student Body
1884
National Anthropological Archives, Smithsonian Institution NAA_73473; Photo Lot 81-12 06824700
http://carlisleindian.dickinson.edu/images/carlisle-indian-school-student-body-version-1-1884
This image shows the student body at Carlisle Indian School. It was taken in 1884 by John N. Choate. Carlisle Indian School, located in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, was the first off-reservation “Indian boarding school” in the United States that was federally run. At a boarding school, students live at the school, not with their families.
During its years of operation (1879 to 1918), around ten thousand Indigenous children attended the Carlisle school. They came from over 100 tribal nations, including the Wabanaki nations. Families in Maine today have memories of relatives attending Carlisle.
Many of the students were forced to attend the school while others attended voluntarily. The school had a particular interest in recruiting the children of tribal leaders so that other parents would cooperate.
There are about 375 students in the image. Note what the children are wearing, how old they look, and how they are positioned. Like many other Native American boarding schools, students at Carlisle Indian School had to wear Anglo-American clothes, cut their hair, speak English instead of their native languages, change their names, and conform to White American culture. Children were punished if they did not follow the rules.
LISTEN TO THE SOUND RECORDING
Click on or copy and paste the link below:http://mainesharedhistory.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Captivity-Outside-Prison_Sound_Clip.mp3
Transcript (written copy of the sound recording):
My great-grandfather was a Tribal leader, Peter Paul. There’s a collection, an archive on him at the University of New Brunswick, which I didn’t know until later in life. Although as a child, my gramp would say to me, you know, ‘You come from good people,’ or whatever.
I did know my, on my mom’s side, my great-grandmother, who we called Grammy Paul, who was a brilliant woman and a healer, and very strict and very correct and mannerly and tidy and so forth.
But I was raised by my mother and my grandfather. He came from Kingsclear, New Brunswick, First Nations. And he told me when I was young that he had been sent to residential school. And his experiences there very much affected him, and then in turn, our family.
My gramp didn’t speak English when they sent him away. He spoke French and he spoke two different Native dialects. I know one was Maliseet, Passamaquoddy dialect. I don’t know what the other one was, it might have been Micmac. And he said, ‘I learned English quick enough.’ Because they would beat him, obviously, for speaking. And, uh, he said they locked him up, you know, in a closet, which I know was typical. My granddad was one of the ones who just couldn’t and wouldn’t accept it. So he told me he kept running away. And he ran away from the residential school in Canada four or five times, and they kept bringing him back.
Now my gramp was an intelligent man. He never graduated from high school. Um, he was brilliant in his way. But I think that generationally, he didn’t have a chance to fulfill his potential because of what happened to him. And so, you can see how quickly the effects of his being taken from his family then shaped the succeeding generations.
Because when you start damaging the family relationships, then people don’t have the kind of support network that they should have. And so I think it makes you easier to succumb to things like substance abuse, because people give up. You know, the despair is so powerful. And then, once you introduce the substance abuse, then you’re adding another layer of problems onto the family structure. And so here we are.
You know, my gramp was born in 1912, and that in that span of time, how much is lost? And I was the only one of four that was taught by him. So I’m the last person in my family to have any sense of a traditional upbringing. To have any knowledge, to have a strong cultural identity. You know? That I have fully internalized. And it’s sad to me to think that my siblings and their children only know of their cultural identity indirectly as a sort of a fact. They don’t have the living experience of it.
Source 3 - Sound Recording
Source 3 - Sound Recording
Statement by Mikhu Paul
December 18, 2014
Collected by Rachel George for the Maine Wabanaki- State Child Welfare Truth and Reconciliation Commission
Bowdoin Digital Commons
Mikhu Paul grew up near the Penobscot Indian Island Reservation near Old Town, Maine and is a member of the Kingsclear First Nation in New Brunswick, Canada. Her story is about her grandfather’s time in a residential school and its impact on her family. “Residential school” is another name for “boarding school.”
Because Maine is close to the border, the children of Wabanaki families were sometimes taken to schools in America, like Carlisle Indian School, and sometimes to schools in Canada. Many Wabanaki families had relatives in both countries and moved freely across the border. After all, the border didn’t exist for much of their history.
Why was Mikhu interviewed? She was one of many people who shared their stories to help people understand the impact of child-welfare practices on Native families. Generations of children like Mikhu’s grandfather have been sent to boarding schools, foster care, or put up for adoption. Stories like this help explain the long-term impacts on families and communities.
More about the project: “The Maine Wabanaki-State Child Welfare Truth and Reconciliation Commission led a truth-seeking process from February 2013 to June 2015 to uncover the truth about child-welfare practice with Maine’s Native people. The Commission and its staff traveled thousands of miles to the villages and communities of Maine to hear people’s testimonies. They reviewed state documents and interviewed over 150 people. They sought to create opportunities for people to heal and learn from what they discovered.” – www.mainewabanakireach.org
Freedom & Captivity Primary Source Sets developed in collaboration between the Maine State Archives, Maine State Library, and Maine State Museum.